My boy is Cherokee & supplies this ax & ns was involved if that is a appropriate term. I believed it originated since the US government historically gave land & together to tribes, climate took it earlier when they uncovered oil or other of worth on the land.

You are watching: Where does indian giver come from


I am going to describe this together the grandson of Crow and also Onondaga people.

Indian giver

This is offensive. We execute not evaluate this usage. Ns don"t treatment where it comes from.

It has been supplied pejoratively due to the fact that at least when ns was exposed to it in the 60s. We offered to respond to it as " median white-man giver." together it was constantly the white government that take it our lands...


I"ve never ever heard this phrase before (I don"t live in the US), so have no instinct ~ above the politics correctness the its daily usage. Once the ahead commenter pointed out Carlyle I determined to execute a google. (I came across Thomas Carlyle when cotranslating part John Stuart Mill texts into German and also he (Carlyle) is definitely not "politically correct".)

In any kind of case there"s an entry at Wikipedia.

"Indian giver" is one American expression, provided to describe a human who gives a "gift" and later wants it back, or that expects something of tantamount worth in return because that the item.

Overall the post seems to suggest that the could cause offence. David Wilton insurance claims the phrase is based upon a misunderstanding where the aboriginal Americans assumed they were trading, while the Europeans assumed the native Americans were giving them a present. Thus -- and this is my subjective expertise -- the definition "to provide a present and also expect miscellaneous in exchange" would certainly be the europe perspective ~ above what happened.

Wiki additionally mentions that the meaning may have adjusted over time.

See more: Is Yeast A Prokaryote Or Eukaryote, Is Yeast Eukaryotic Or Prokaryotic


The expression was very first noted in 1765 by thomas Hutchinson, who defined an Indian gift together "a existing for which an equivalent return is expected,"<4><5> which says that the phrase initially referred come a an easy exchange that gifts. In 1860, however, in man Russell Bartlett"s thesaurus of Americanisms, Bartlett stated the expression was being supplied by children in new York to median "one who provides a present and then takes it back."<6>

As freshly as 1979, the phrase was provided in mainstream media publications,<7> yet in the 1997 publication The shade of Words: an Encyclopaedic dictionary of Ethnic prejudice in the joined States, writer and also editor Philip H. Herbst claims that back the phrase is frequently used innocently by children, it might be taken as offensive,<8> and also The Copyeditor"s Handbook (1999) explains it as objectionable.<9>