Why bother Potter Movies adjusted Dumbledore's death (& Made the Worse) The harry Potter movies made some transforms to the best scenes native the books, consisting of Dumbledore"s fatality – and actually made it worse.

You are watching: How did harry know that dumbledore was dead


Although the Harry Potter movie collection did a an excellent job in adapting J.K. Rowling Wizarding world to the large screen, it had to either omit or adjust many scene to far better fit the layout – and also for dramatic purposes. Together is the case of the death of Albus Dumbledore in Harry Potter and also the Half-Blood Prince, i m sorry was changed in means that pan weren’t entirely on board with and that actually hurt the scene.

Readers around the people were presented to the Wizarding human being in 1997, once Harry Potter and the Philosopher’s Stone to be published. The publication was followed by six more, telling the story that “the boy who lived” and his battle versus the darkest sorcerer’s of all: mr Voldemort. The publications were later adapted into eight movies (with Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows being split into two), bringing the human being of bother Potter come a new audience. As it happens v every cinematic adaptation the a book, countless characters, scenes, and also events were left out of the movies, and some others were readjusted for various reasons.


Related: bother Potter Movies ruined Fred Weasley"s Death

One the the many emotional moment in the Harry Potter series is Dumbledore’s death. The beloved hogwarts headmaster and also the one magician Voldemort was afraid the met his fate in the sixth book, but his death in the movie was very different to the one in the resource material, and it in reality hurt the initial scene.

The actual Reason Dumbledore’s death Was readjusted In The Movie


Harry Potter Dumbledore fatality Half-Blood Prince
Albus Dumbledore died during the battle of the Astronomy Tower (also well-known as the fight of the Lightning-Struck Tower). As Lucius Malfoy failure to acquire the prophecy throughout the battle of the ministry of Magic, Voldemort notified Draco Malfoy to death Dumbledore, knowing an extremely well the he couldn’t carry out it provided that Dumbledore’s strength and an abilities were above his. Narcissa Malfoy, fearing it was all a arrangement to have actually Malfoy killed in revenge versus Lucius, request Severus Snape to help Draco and complete the mission if he couldn’t. This deal was sealed through an Unbreakable Vow.


After obtaining among the horcruxes native a cave, Harry and Dumbledore went back to Hogsmeade, wherein Madam Rosmerta warned them the the Dark Mark appeared over the Astronomy Tower. Dumbledore and also Harry borrowed her broomsticks and also headed increase there, advertisement Dumbledore immobilized Harry with a silent complete body-bind curse and covered him through the invisibility cloak. Dumbledore then hid harry in a dark bunker under the platform. Draco arrived, along with other death Eaters, yet couldn’t bring himself to kill Dumbledore. Snape suddenly appeared and, ~ Dumbledore pleaded through him (as to not raise hesitation over Snape’s real allegiance and also the overall plan), Snape proceeded to death him. The scene played out differently in the movie: Snape and also Narcissa did have a deal, and Draco was complied with by death Eaters (though not the exact same ones as in the book), yet the remainder was adjusted in means that no appeal to fans.

See more: What Was The Main Occupation In New Hampshire Colony Facts, What Was The Main Occupation In New Hampshire


Dumbledore and also Harry apparated come the height platform of the Astronomy Tower – they never came across with Rosmerta, nor was the Dark note over the tower. Harry wasn’t frozen through Dumbledore, and was rather instructed to go and hide listed below the platform. Snape suddenly showed up next to Harry and told him to stay silent, climate proceeded upstairs to kill Dumbledore. In enhancement to every that, the fight of the stimulate of the Phoenix versus the death Eaters wasn’t included, as director David Yates want to prevent repetition through the battle of Hogwarts, comes in the eighth movie. The was an extremely out of character for Harry to just remain quiet and also not do anything while his mentor was being killed, though it can be justified by that trusting Snape would never ever kill Dumbledore. Neither Yates no one anyone else affiliated in Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince have revealed their reasoning behind these changes, yet it might simply be as result of narrative (and dramatic) purposes, offering Harry more reasons come dislike Snape, as he reliable him to conserve Dumbledore, despite it ended up hurting the Dumbledore/Harry dynamic.