The scriptures lists pets that are fit or unfit for human being consumption. Yet only birds not suitable to eat are contained in the list. For this reason which bird are edible?


*

Does God consider duck a food we deserve to eat? that is thought about a clean bird by the Jews, however some human being have wondered about this.

You are watching: Can seventh-day adventists eat duck

For example, some note that both Leviticus 11:18 and Deuteronomy 14:16 in the King James version list the swan together unclean—a bird that “shall no be eaten” (Leviticus 11:13). Some argue that the duck is component of the swan family; therefore, if the swan is not suitable for human being consumption, climate so is the duck. This reasoning uses the rule of “according to its kind,” and also places the duck according to the swan kind. (The expression “according to its kind” is taken native the creation record in Genesis.) according to this argument, one would certainly conclude the duck is unclean and should no be eaten.

But is this correct? many authorities concur that “swan” is an not correct translation in the original King James variation of the Bible. Most modern English translations that Leviticus and Deuteronomy perform not have actually the native “swan,” yet rather, “white owl” or “little owl” together in the two following examples:

Leviticus 11:18: “The white owl, the desert owl, the osprey” (New international Version); “the white owl, the jackdaw, and the carrion vulture” (New King James Version).Deuteronomy 14:16: “The small owl, the great owl, the white owl” (NIV); “the tiny owl, the screech owl, the white owl” (NKJV).

Consider the Hebrew message of Leviticus 11:18

The Hebrew native tanshemeth (Strong’s Exhaustive Concordance #8580) is provided to designate an unclean creature (unfit for person consumption). Tanshemeth is used twice in Leviticus and once in Deuteronomy.The Biblia Hebraica Stuttgartensia says “swan” is a mistranslation.Leeser’s Old testimony English translation of the Hebrew Bible states, “It is inaccurate to interpret the Hebrew indigenous tanshemeth, together swan.”

Additionally, the Tanakh: A brand-new Translation the the holy Scriptures according to the classic Hebrew Text has actually the “white owl” or “little owl,” not “swan.” there is no cite of swans, geese or ducks together being unclean.

Moreover, speak of the swan, the International Standard holy bible Encyclopedia states, “White and also gray swans … are amongst the most ancient birds of history; always have been supplied for food; … so there is no opportunity that lock were ever before rightfully placed amongst the birds unsuitable for food” (“Swan”).

Below space two much more reasons some world argue that ducks or geese room unclean (unsuitable because that food).

They space web-footed birds. However, nothing in Scripture supports this argument. The hatchet “web-footed” is no in the Bible.Others argue the ducks and also geese are scavengers and that lock are as such unsuitable for food. However, the behavior of these birds prove otherwise. They space not scavengers, and also the holy bible does not state they space scavengers.

What an animal eats does no make that “clean” or “unclean”

There space some who believe what an pet eats provides it clean or unclean. While that is true that birds the prey space all unclean, one animal’s diet doesn’t carry out a complete an interpretation of even if it is it is clean or unclean. From researching the perform in Leviticus 11 and also Deuteronomy 14 we deserve to conclude the it’s just how God make an animal, fish or bird that makes it clean or unclean (unfit for person consumption).

As an example, a horse eats mainly grass, hay, oats, barley, flax, etc., and also yet steed meat is unclean, not fit for human being consumption. The is not what an pet eats, but the way its flesh was designed from development that makes the difference. Moreover, you could feed a limit pig a healthy and balanced mixture of only grain, yet doing so would not change the flesh of the pig—neither steeds nor pigs were produced for person consumption, according to the Creator.

Dr. Mockery Axe discusses the digestive system of the pig in his article “Why You should Avoid Pork”: “There are reasons that the meat the the pig becomes more saturated v toxins than countless of its counterpart farm animals.”

In enhancement to the means the pet was designed by God, steed meat often consists of a chemistry poisonous come humans, according to Melanie Jones in this International organization Times article: “Horse Slaughter approved in U.S.: 5 reasons Not to Eat equine Meat.”

The biblical perform is no intended to it is in an exhaustive source; it gives us guidelines whereby we have the right to make an excellent judgments. We must look to added sources because that information around the habits and also characteristics that clean and also unclean birds in stimulate to determine which persons are suitable for food.In both Leviticus 11 and also Deuteronomy 14, fewer than two dozen bird are noted as examples of birds that one need to not eat. Follow to some sources, there are roughly 8,616 varieties of birds in the world!

Obviously, the biblical list is no intended to be an exhaustive source; it provides us guidelines through which we can make good judgments. We must look to added sources for information around the habits and also characteristics the clean and also unclean bird in order to identify which persons are an ideal for food.

The Talmud

In the Talmud (a combination of the first five publications of Bible and also oral traditions of rabbis, pass down through the ages prior to being created down) the variety of unclean birds is 24. The bible lists 20 and also the oral traditions include four extr ones. The Talmud climate states, “The clean birds room without number” (Hul. 63b).

The six qualities of the clean birds provided in this resource are:

They space not bird of prey.They have a supernumerary toe (ezba yeterah), which is construed to typical either secondary toe behind the others, or an elongation the the middle toe.They are supplied with a crop.Their stomachs have actually two skins that can be easily separated.They capture food thrown to them in the air, but bring it to the ground, where they division it with their bills before eating it, when the unclean birds devour that in the air, or push it v one foot to the ground and tear it with their bills.They should spread your toes so that 3 front toes are on one next of a perch and also the hind one on the various other side the the perch.

(Articles in the Jewish Encyclopedia under “poultry” and “clean and also unclean animals” provide additional helpful information.)

An interesting point to think about is the truth that the dove and also the pigeon were anciently provided for sacrifice (and to offer a sacrifice follow to what is said in the legislation of the Lord, “A pair of turtledoves or two young pigeons.”

new King James version (NKJV) The holy Bible, brand-new King James variation ©1982 by thomas Nelson">Luke 2:24;

‘And if the burnt sacrifice that his giving to the lord is that birds, climate he shall carry his giving of turtledoves or young pigeons. The priest shall carry it to the altar, wring off its head, and burn the on the altar; that blood shall it is in drained out at the side of the altar. And also he shall remove its chop with that feathers and also cast it alongside the altar on the eastern side, right into the place for ashes. Then he shall split it in ~ its wings, yet shall no divide it completely; and also the monk shall burn that on the altar, top top the timber that is ~ above the fire. The is a scorched sacrifice, an offering made through fire, a sweet aroma to the Lord.

brand-new King James version (NKJV) The divine Bible, brand-new King James version ©1982 by thomas Nelson">Leviticus 1:14-17). Thus, the characteristics of these two birds are advantageous in identify which fowl space clean or unclean. Both of these birds to the right the six descriptions given over for birds the are perfect for food.

Additional information

Clean birds have, in essence, three stomachs: a crop, a gizzard and also another section in between the two. This avoids poisons from gift assimilated right into their meat comparable to the means the digestive procedure works in ruminant pets (which have a collection of 4 stomachs).

One argument says a duck walk not have a chop (an expandable muscular pouch near the gullet or throat used to keep food for later on digestion) and therefore concludes that the bird is not suitable for person consumption. However, anatomically, duck do have a crop. The crop on a duck, unlike that on a chicken or a turkey, is little an ext than a widening of the esophagus; but it is a crop, nonetheless.

“Leaf-eating birds such as swans, geese, grouse, ducks and other video game birds, have actually bacteria in their intestines which break down cellulose. Pigeons and doves use their chop to store, or partially digest, food taken too conveniently for the stomach to handle. Throughout the brooding the chop produces ‘milk’ from seeds eaten, which is regurgitated because that the young. This is one type of rumination, making this clean birds similar to clean animals, which chew their cud” (Robert Burton, Bird Behavior, 1985, p. 76).

See more: Is A Potato A Monocot Or Dicot S, What Is The Classification Of Potato

In conclusion

Based on the details presented in this article and also since the bible does not point out specifically the ducks are unclean, we believe the duck, as well as the swan, to it is in a clean bird.

For an ext about what the scriptures teaches around meats that must or have to not be eaten, view the ar on “Clean and Unclean Animals: walk God care What Meats we Eat?”and the graph “Clean and Unclean Meats.”