There space two calibers that dominate the concealed bring scene; the 38 Special and also its large brother, the 357 Magnum

When shopping because that a revolver, i beg your pardon one should you choose?

The 38 distinct is a .357-caliber cartridge the was originally developed in 1898. It was initially intended to push a 158-grain cartridge by method of black powder. Over the 122 years since the 38 one-of-a-kind was introduced, pistol powder and also the toughness of gun stole evolved, and today’s 38 distinct Silvertip load sends a 110-grain bullet at 945 feet-per-second (FPS), achieving 218 ft.-lbs. Of energy at the muzzle.

You are watching: Can a 357 shoot 38 special


Unlike rebated-rim cartridges intended for semiautomatic handguns, the 38 Special functions a rimmed situation that enables it to it is in safely loaded and extracted in the cylinders of revolvers. The modern-day 38 distinct endures, due to the fact that it’s a soft recoiling ring that has proven itself accurate and effective. It remains most likely the world’s most well-known revolver round.

In 1934, gun authors Elmer Keith and also Phillip Sharpe upped the strength of the currently 38 special by merely including a more heavier dose of smokeless flour to its case. The an ext powerful round was designed particularly for legislation enforcement to accomplish greater penetration through practical barrier materials. The result cartridge was called the 357 Magnum. However, the inner pressures that resulted can dangerously ruin older weapons intended for the less powerful 38 Special, so the 357 Magnum’s case was re-designed 1/8th-inch longer to protect against it from being loaded right into a 38 unique revolver. Today,’s 357 Magnum Silvertip round launches a 145-grain bullet at 1290 FPS through 536 ft.-lbs. That energy. That’s much more than twin the muzzle energy of the 38 Special. That course, recoil is additionally nearly dual as well.

But here’s the deal: due to the fact that the two rounds are loaded with bullets that room the exact same diameters, yet the 357 Magnum merely has a longer instance and more powder, the 38 distinct cartridge can be safe fired in guns marked 357 Magnum, but not vice-versa. This way that if you acquisition a 357 Magnum revolver, you have the right to shoot 38 Special lots in it for practice, then choose the an ext potent 357 Mag rounds for defense. The downside to purchase a 357 Magnum revolver, is that weapons designed exclusively for the 38 Special deserve to be made smaller and lighter, so if pistol size and weight is your main concern, the 38 Special might be the far better choice.

See more: Can Cherries Make Your Poop Red Stool, Common Causes Of Red Or Black Stool


So, if you room recoil perceptible or desire the the smallest revolver girlfriend can get that still has actually adequate downrange power, the 38 Special could be the way to go. If you don’t mind a little recoil and also believe the a couple of extra ounces the gun weight is precious nearly dual the downrange energy, the 357 Mag is your ideal bet. And besides, girlfriend can constantly shoot the much less expensive, lower-power 38 Specials if you change your mind.